Verification of Unusual Sight Record
For Utah

Rec. # 2020-51


Common name:

Magnolia Warbler

Scientific name: Setophaga magnolia
Date: 9/26/2020 (first observed on 9/25 - see other observer notes)
Time: 11:00 AM
Length of time observed: 5 minutes
Number: 1
Age:  
Sex: Female
Location: Confluence Park (La Verkin) - along Virgin River
County: Washington
Latilong: 37.2001516, -113.2863452
Elevation:  
Distance to bird: Varied - 15 to 40 feet
Optical equipment: 8x42 binoculars and 500 mm lens
Weather: Sunny, warm
Light Conditions: Full sun
Description:        Size of bird: Small passerine
(Description:)       Basic Shape: Warbler
(Description:)  Overall Pattern: Gray, yellow
(Description:)            Bill Type: Thin, straight
(Description:)                              
Field Marks and
Identifying Characteristics:
This warbler immediately stood out from nearby orange-crowned warblers due to its brighter yellow underparts and presence of two contrasting white wingbars on dark wings. Closer looks gave us a good glimpse of the gray head, complete white eyering, and extensively yellow underparts with limited but fairly dark flank streaking. I did not see the underside of the tail. However, the undertail coverts were obviously white from my limited view. Its yellowish back contrasted with its gray head/nape and darker wings. Yellow rump was also visible. Wing and tail feathers both appeared dark with contrastingly pale edging. Obtained brief looks and poor photos of unique upper-tail pattern when the bird briefly spread its tail.
(see photos)
Song or call & method of delivery: Not heard.
Behavior: Gleaning tiny insects off of phragmites
Habitat: Riparian along Virgin River (observed in mesquite and phragmites)
Similar species and how
were they eliminated:
Nashville Warbler: Probably the most likely, vaguely similar species. However, easily ruled out since this species lacks wingbars and streaking on flanks, and has yellow (not white) undertail coverts.

Canada Warbler: This species does not have wingbars and shows no dark streaking on flanks. Upper-side would be uniformly gray (lacking yellow). Loral area would show obvious yellow.

Northern Parula: Would show very white belly and flanks with no dark flank streaking. Always shows eye arcs and never a complete eye-ring. Also, would show dark lores and eyeline.

Prairie Warbler: Would show more extensive yellow upperparts, and yellowish (rather than white) wingbars. Would also show a more markings on the face, and a dark spot on the sides of the neck. Undertail coverts would be more yellowish instead of clean white.
Previous experience with
this & similar species:
None with Magnolia and none or very limited with other similar eastern warblers. Very familiar with Nashville Warbler, which migrates through Utah every fall.
References consulted: Sibley Bird App
Description from:  
Observer: Mike Schijf
Observer's address: 109 South 330 West
Observer's e-mail address: **
Other observers who independently identified this bird: 9/25/2020: MAWA was found by Steve and Cindy Sommerfeld and was observed later in the day by Maurice DeMille.
9/26/2020: First relocated by Kevin Wheeler. Later that morning, I observed this bird with John Schijf, Marshall Topham, Seth Topham, and Kaylie Topham.
Has been subsequently observed by Rick Fridell, Lucy Ormond, Rachel LeBlanc, and perhaps others.
 
Date prepared: 09/30/2020
Additional material: Photos
Additional comments: Still present as of 9/30, according to eBird reports.